The Cyprus Conflict

˜

Historiography & Nationalism


Among the wellsprings of the Cyprus conflict are differing interpretations of history - - historical narratives, now well established, which provide each nation with a set of interpretations, rationales, and legends about the past to distinguish itself from the other side. These narratives are one of the roots of nationalism, of identity as a nation with its own particular history, a history of struggle against insuperable odds and obstacles, and a struggle against the malevolence of the other, competing national groups. Over the last fifty years, the narratives of Greek Cypriots and Turkish Cypriots have taken shape, wound up with each other and with the motherlands, and forged in the bitter fighting that began in the late 1950s and continued to August 1974. Not surprisingly, the narratives that have emerged over these fifty years support the dominant political ideas of the two groups: in Greek Cyprus, the narrative spins on the heroic struggle against British colonialism, then jumps to the Turkish invasion of 1974, insisting all the while that the two Cypriot groups lived peacefully all along. The Turkish Cypriot narrative is a tale of neglect, of a callous Greek Cypriot majority ignoring their rightful place as partners in the future of the island, abruptly overthrowing the constitution, and forcing them into enclaves of deprivation and humiliation until rescued by the Turkish army. Their lesson is that the two did not live peaceably together and cannot do so in the future.

The principal purpose of this Web site is to provide tools to build a common narrative of sorts by presenting a range of documents and scholarly literature. Another way of considering a common narrative is to Adeconstruct@ the nationalistic narratives that have so long framed the political discourse throughout the island. This section undertakes to present precisely that historiography, through the work of several distinguished scholars. This work is among the most important in the world on the topics of political narratives, memory, and nationalism. It is presented with the understanding that political elites (including politicians, journalists, and educators) on both sides have engaged in a conscious manipulation of historical events to support their ideological prejudices. The conflict cannot finally be settled without a reckoning with the past that supercedes nationalist myths and opens both sides to an honest, self-critical, and balanced history.

˜

The work here is not listed in any particular order. Some of the historical accounts in other sections of the site also present important insights about the construction of history. Readers should also consult the reading lists, footnotes, and other citations to pursue their interests in this set of topics.


Conflict Between the States of Cyprus, 1963-1974, Zenon Stavrinides

Greek Irredentism in Asia Minor and Cyprus, by Paschalis Kitromilides

Turkish Nationalism, Then and Now, by Dogu Ergil

The Politics of Memory and Forgetting, Yiannis Papadakis

Greek-Cypriot Nationalism and Cypriotism 1974-1995, by Caesar Mavratsas

Nationalist Imaginings of War in Cyprus, Yiannis Papadakis

Communal Memory and Turkish Cypriot National History, by Nergis Canefe

Psychohistory and Cyprus, by John Mack

The Church's Message, in the Jubilee Year 2000

Isaiah Berlin and George Orwell on Nationalism

Other readings on nationalism